| News & Citizen | |||||||||||||||||
| Serving the People of Lamoille County with News Since 1881 | |||||||||||||||||
|
FMarch 3, 2010 Thursday Morrisville, VT 05661 Web Edition |
|||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
News & Citizen
P.O. Box 369 Morrisville, Vermont 05661 802-888-2212 webmaster dan@kingdomsedge.com |
Editorial by J.B. McKinley 2-18-10
Three Days Off
This editor perceives the current situation with the Morristown school budget as having thrown taxpayers a bone that comes off more like a sound bite than a genuine concession. But it does appear to solve the immediate conflicts between saving and spending.
I’m talking about the fact that the union and administration compromised by lopping off three days of teaching, cost/savings – $70,000. Yes, Morristown teachers will get three days less pay (presumably so will paras, custodians, etc.), but the union will save several .4 positions and everyone will get three days more vacation. Is this a concession bearing anything close to what some folks in town are experiencing as they visit the food shelf, stop their prescription to pay for fuel, or look for a job while drawing unemployment?
Let’s not look too far for comparisons; let’s look at Stowe. Teachers postponed a hefty raise to save other teachers’ jobs, though presumably other motives were involved, too.
One ponders other questions... there is the 4% already negotiated pay raise in the the Morristown contract. Might it be large enough to effectively cause no pay cut for Morristown teachers?
One remembers that former Lamoille Superintendent Alice Angney wanted Morristown to go to school longer than other schools in the area, partly to raise test scores. Thinking about this, one can’t help but remember the recently announced NECAP scores. I am not casting the blame on superintendents, or anyone in particular, for the state of affairs as regards NECAP results anywhere in our area. For example, it seems absolutely ridiculous to blame Ms. Wrend for scores in Morristown, without praising her to the skies for scores in Stowe. And this column is not about blame it’s about money.
Where to squeeze the budget was this year’s really important question and ultimately requires a decision by the taxpayers. Unfortunately by Town Meeting time, this is only a yes or no question. Tough decisions on the relative importance of sport, art and academics will definitely be coming down the pike if budgets continue to take a beating. There’s only one day left to strike from the school year in Morristown and it’s worth about $25,000. It’s pretty clear that this year’s fix won’t work next year.
A question to consider, when looking at cuts in the future, is where or how, or do pay scales affect test scores? Test scores are complexly affected beforehand. For example, is it the teacher cadre that has the most effect, is it student demographics, or is it the money spent per pupil?
We are certainly going to hear rationales for why some schools don’t appear to be performing as well as others. It will be up to us if we agree with those arguments. Ultimately it will be up to voters and their elected school boards to consider the big picture as both contract time and budget time roll around again. It’s clear money availability is no longer open-ended. How will we apportion what we have?