| News & Citizen | |||||||||||||||||||
| Serving the People of Lamoille County with News Since 1881 | |||||||||||||||||||
|
Volume 123 No 10 No 5569 March 1 2007 Thursday Morrisville, VT 05661 Web Edition |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
Things Look This Way to Me
Editorial by J.B. McKinley 3/1/07
Who’s Giving Whom a Break?
Nope, it wasn’t the need for a half million dollars of new roof. Nope, it wasn’t the request for a new back-up ambulance. Yep, it was the explanation of a new veterans’ benefit that had me instantly steaming and ashamed of state politics and government.
It is not the fact of being able to offer veterans a bigger break on their property taxes based on exempting up to $40,000 of their assessment. It was the cheap, penny ante, two-bit weaselly manner in which the state passed the buck to the towns to pay for this break. It brings to mind some sleazeball bum putting on a pressed suitcoat from the Salvation Army, walking into an upscale restaurant looking like a gent, ordering in a tony fake accent, eating and leaving without paying the check.
What am I talking about? Well, I’m trusting Morristown Town Clerk Mary Ann Wilson to have it right. She explained last night that for many years Vermont towns have been granting certain veterans, first, a $10,000 exemption on their property taxes. About 10 years ago this amount was allowed to go up to $20,000. Now, in a moment of generosity and supposed recognition of the debt owed to veterans the state has allowed towns to offer up to a $40,000 exemption. That sounds great, right? Personally, I would support the new level as a nice gesture. Though not really a big deal given today’s assessments of our residences, I’m told this would give 21 Morristown veterans a pleasant tax break.
And so it will, but the state included a Catch-22. The state won’t let its tax collections go down! The state will only subsidize the first $10,000. Presumably that means, since Morristown voters had already authorized the $20,000 exemption, we taxpayers will even have to make up the taxes owed on that $10,000 boost, plus whatever we all decide to authorize this year, up to the $40,000 level.
Let me state my position. I think the $40,000 exemption is a compassionate move that Morristown and other towns can probably afford, as Mrs. Wilson says it will cost us 1/3 of a cent on Morristown’s tax rate. But I think the Legislature is a parsimonious and hypocritical body in this case. Either give the tax break and forgo the taxes or pass no law.
Montpelier, either honor veterans or don’t. Don’t tell the towns “You pay for our charity.” Folks, lots of this kind of lawmaking with the check being passed down the line, but this example is as blatant as can possibly be. Hey, Montpelier, really want to be cheap, next time pass a resolution, that’s free and might even be sincere.